Payment Processing

The Pros and Cons of Flat-Rate vs. Interchange-Plus Pricing for Credit Card Processing

Table of Contents

Categories List

Modern commerce operates at a breakneck pace, and processing credit card payments is essential for businesses of all size. Nonetheless, swiping a card is deceptively simple: a maze of credit card processing fees swirls behind the scenes and can have a major impact on a company’s bottom line. Indeed, several credit card processing pricing models prove that selecting the most suitable one for your business is a vitally important decision that may make or break your company’s financial health.

To demystify this complex system of fees, we will embark on a fascinating journey. Two main types of pricing meet most businesses: flat-rate pricing and interchange-plus pricing. Understanding their distinct features is key to making an educated decision in line with the unique needs of any business.

Understanding Flat-Rate Pricing

Another pricing model that ensures simplicity and clarity is flat-rate pricing. In simple words, it means that you, as a business owner, pay a fixed amount for each transaction with a credit card. The good news is that this fixed sum covers the charge for a transaction, which is easy to keep in mind.

Throughout an example, this transparent spending method can be easily understood. For instance, a small jewelry online boutique decides to set up flat-rate pricing with a payment processor, charging 2.9% + $0.30. If a customer buys a $50 necklace with a credit card, a business will pay $1.75 in fees ($50*2.9% + $0.30) .

Now, let’s find out why flat-rate pricing is so convenient according to many entrepreneurs. To begin with, when each transaction costs the same, it is clear to understand what a fee will be, which is beneficial for small and starting businesses. Second, the whole model is simplified in the terms of counting since it is transparent, and it requires no hidden calculations.

So, if a small or start-up business has low or average monthly payments, a flat-rate model is cost-effective. Also, the user-friendly interface of the majority of payment processors makes their services operating in hours from installation.

The Pros of Flat-Rate Pricing

Flat-rate pricing may seem like a flat idea, but it’s a beacon of simplicity in a complicated credit card processing world.

Learn about these staggering benefits of flat-rate pricing: predictability and simplicity. Predictability is the most striking benefit of flat-rate processing. You know precisely how much you’ll be charged per transaction. Instead, you spend hours trying to calculate your credit card processing expenses.

Since it makes financial planning and budgeting easier due to its predictability, it safeguards your peace of mind. Regardless of the number of transactions you perform, you can be certain the cost per transaction will remain the same. Secondly, flat-rate pricing promotes a high level of payment processing awareness since this simple structure allows for more accurate cost projection.

The predictability of the pricing also means that there will be no surprise costs associated with the service. Flat rate pricing is becoming increasingly popular in the online paying processing industry. Thirdly, it is more clear and straight forward.

Because the sector seems to be a labyrinth of fees and tariffs, flat-rate processing is a refreshing change with no hidden costs or complex multi-tiered frameworks. Thus, as a business owner, if you have a clear image of your rates and charges, you can glue your eyes to your finances.

The Cons of Flat-Rate Pricing

Flat-rate pricing comes with several caveats and may not always be the most viable choice:

1. Not the cheapest option for larger businesses: While an apparent advantage, the smaller fee doesn’t benefit higher-volume credit card processors. Due to a flat fee’s fixed nature, the more transactions get processed, the higher the amount in final processing fees is.

As a result, larger businesses pay more for their smaller advantage, as the simplicity of fixed fees may come at a heftier price.

2. Not the best choice for a high amount of transactions: Another valued feature is the low charge for processing a high number of transactions . However, businesses that consistently process a very high volume of credit card payments might find themselves paying more than they would with other types of pricing.

3. Flat-rate is not the best choice in all scenarios: Depending on the specifics of your business, flat-rate pricing may not even cut as the most cost-effective. . In comparison to flat-rate pricing, models like interchange-plus  often cost less since they provide great convenience. If your business primarily conducts transactions with foreign parties, the price will undoubtedly fluctuate.

Due to higher interchange fees associated with cross-border transactions,  flat-rate pricing will set you back more money. Likewise, particularly niche fields with unique processing requirements will find flat-rate pricing an unviable option.

Understanding Interchange-Plus Pricing

Unlike the simplicity of flat-rate pricing, interchange-plus pricing offers a more open and detailed view of the business’ credit card processing fees.

The following covers interchange-plus pricing in its entirety: definition according to how it works and the transparency element. Specifically, interchange plus, also known as cost-plus, is a credit card processing pricing model where businesses are charged the actual interchange fee determined by card networks plus a markup fee the payment processor or merchant services provider charges . In other words, interchange-plus pricing separates the interchange fee set by the card networks and the processor’s markup set as the plus .

The interchange fee consists of the fee card networks charge for processing a given transaction, and it can vary according to the type of card, transaction method, and compliance with the laws and regulations based on an industry. The plus is the margin the payment processor charges and is equal to a percentage of the transaction cost plus an additional standard fixed fee. In other words, interchange plus is a two-tier pricing structure: one, the cost of transaction and two: the profit margin .

One of the pros is transparency. Specifically, businesses gain insight into the exact payment for the interchange fee and the exact payment to the processing processor as a markup. As a result, such transparency enables businesses to truly comprehend their processing costs and better the payment processing strategy.

The Pros of Interchange-Plus Pricing

Although it may appear more complicated than flat-rate pricing, interchange-plus pricing offers several advantages over this option, especially for certain types of businesses: . These pros include:

  • Cost savings. Businesses that process high transaction volumes often save money with interchange-plus pricing. Because the processors’ markups are generally less than the flat-rate percentages, this payment method guarantees that most companies doing a high level of transactions will be cheaper.

  • Cost control. Interchange-plus pricing offers visibility into the actual interchange fees established by the card networks. This essential detail allows you to determine methods to reduce fees, such as prompting consumers to utilize lower-cost methods of payment or addressing other particular processing concerns that might push them up.

  • Utility and scalability. It is a good fit for all sectors, regardless of size or scope. Furthermore, you may adjust your rate according to your criteria. In other terms, you can pay as much as you can afford every month. Your transaction fees may be adjusted to suit your needs as your businesses grow.

  • Customization. Businesses may adjust their price structure based on the volume of transactions, type of transaction, and sector. Transactions are given a grade based on the risk of the transaction. If the transaction is less likely to cause a chargeback, a lower rate is applied.

The Cons of Interchange-Plus Pricing

Nevertheless, interchange-plus pricing undoubtedly has its disadvantages and situations when it may not be the most suitable option. The aspects that should be considered beforehand include the following: Complexity.

It is clear that interchange-plus pricing is more complex compared to flat-rate pricing. The pricing breakdown includes fees, and the interchange fee together with the processor’s markup is two separate components . It might be a challenge for the unexperienced or smaller businesses who may find this complexity complicated.

They will be unable to understand the price structure, leading to inability to control the credit card processing costs effectively. Less predictability. Interchange-plus pricing is less predictable compared to flat-rate pricing when the transaction cost is fixed.

The interchange fee component is prone to fluctuate depending on the card type and the transaction detail. This makes it difficult for businesses to determine the exact amount needed for accurate budgeting, especially when there is a large amount of varying transactions. Potential performance fee.

Even when interchange-plus pricing is clear and exhibited, there is still the risk of future potential fees. Some processors may include extra chargers or mask certain fees in the markup component that is not obvious for businesses. Therefore, to avoid unexpected costs and ensure transparency, businesses must verify their processing statements and quotes thoroughly.

Choosing the Right Pricing Model for Your Business

Making the right pricing model selection for credit processing is crucial to a business. To make the right choice, follow these steps: assess your business’s needs based on your specific needs and circumstances, however small businesses and start-ups with modest transaction volumes may favor flat-rate pricing for simplicity and predictability. In contrast, many firms with high sales volumes can take advantage of the potential cost savings provided by interchange-plus pricing ; take into account the nature of your industry, as different industries demand distinct payment processing needs and cost structures.

For example, flat-rate pricing may benefit the retail environment due to the simplicity of fixed rates, while interchange-plus provides more cost-effective processing for other industries such as e-commerce or B2B, which is highly differentiated among numerous transaction types and values ; understand your financial constraints and how much you are willing to commit to credit card processing. While many studies have recommended interchange-plus pricing as a result of the potential savings, it requires more thorough and specific financial management to completely realize these savings ; compare provider quotes and do not hesitate to acquire quotes from multiple payment processors or merchant services. This important exercises will enable you to assess the competitive environment and obtain a pricing model that reflects your needs and financial constraints.

Also, ensure that all additional fees are requested and give a cost breakdown to maintain transparency; if you feel overwhelmed by the pricing models and options available, consider seeking advice from a financial advisor or specialists in payment processing. They may provide valuable insights to facilitate the decision-making process.


RapidCents specializes in helping businesses like yours navigate the labyrinth of credit card processing. r team of experts will provide personal online payment solutions that meet your needs so you can confidently access the financial resources your business deserves. Contact us today and see what we can do for you.

Online Payment is now a piece of cake.

Join now.
Scroll to Top

Get In Touch.

We're always willing to help.

Fill in the form to get in touch with someone on our team, and we will reach out shortly.

Please visit the support portal for our FAQs.
Unable to find answers?
Submit a ticket and we will get back to you shortly.

Contact us today!

Send us an e-mail!